DHCR Clarifies Rent Concessions: What Owners and Purchasers Should Know
A temporary rent concession can have consequences that extend well beyond the lease in which it appears. For owners of rent-stabilized apartments, whether a concession establishes a preferential rent can affect future renewal increases, rental income, and potential overcharge exposure.
DHCR’s November 2026 update to Fact Sheet #40 provides an important clarification: temporary rent concessions and preferential rents remain distinct concepts, and the agency’s 2019 revision was not intended to eliminate that distinction. Whether a particular arrangement qualifies as a concession depends on its facts and circumstances.
Why the distinction matters
Under the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, a preferential rent generally continues for the duration of the tenancy, with lawful increases calculated from that lower rent. Consequently, a discount intended to apply during one lease term may affect subsequent renewals if it functions as a preferential rent.
Consider a hypothetical twelve-month lease stating a monthly rent of $4,000 and providing one month free. The average monthly cost is approximately $3,666.67. That calculation describes the economics of the arrangement; it does not, standing alone, determine the lawful renewal rent. The legal question is whether the arrangement constitutes a temporary concession or establishes a lower preferential rent.
What DHCR clarified
The revised guidance identifies several considerations: the circumstances prompting the abatement, conditions affecting the property or residential occupancy, the abatement’s duration and temporary nature, and the agreement’s actual language.
For owners, the practical implication is that the documentation should explain the arrangement and accurately reflect how it operates. Calling a discount a “concession” does not resolve its legal treatment.
How the clarification relates to recent court decisions
The update follows significant First Department decisions addressing concessions offered after the HSTPA.
In Grey v. LIC Development Owner, L.P., decided in March 2026, the court relied in part on what it understood to be a change in DHCR’s guidance following the 2019 revision of Fact Sheet #40. It affirmed relief concerning post-HSTPA concessions while distinguishing concessions offered before the statute’s enactment.
In Choi v. Linc LIC L.L.C., decided in May 2026, the court likewise discussed the revised fact sheet. Its analysis also considered the owner’s advertising of a net effective rent and an agreement providing six months of concessions purportedly related to COVID-19. The court concluded that the concessions functioned as a preferential rent.
DHCR’s latest clarification provides a basis for owners to challenge the premise that the agency intended to abandon the concession/preferential-rent distinction. Its effect on particular disputes remains a question for further administrative and judicial consideration. The update itself does not reverse those decisions or establish that every temporary discount is permissible.
Practical steps for owners and managing agents
Owners should use this development in DHCR's guidance as an opportunity to review concession practices with counsel:
Examine the complete leasing record. Review the lease, concession rider, advertisements, correspondence, rent ledger, and subsequent renewals together.
Preserve contemporaneous support. Maintain records explaining why the concession was offered and how its duration was determined.
Review implementation. Confirm that billing and collection practices match the written agreement.
Evaluate renewals before increasing rent. Determine the appropriate renewal base rather than assuming that the stated lease rent controls.
Reassess existing disputes. Consider whether the clarification supports additional arguments in pending concession or overcharge matters.
These are recommended review steps; their significance will depend on the particular tenancy and governing law.
A due diligence issue for purchasers and lenders
Concessions also deserve attention when evaluating a building’s income and regulatory exposure.
A rent roll may identify a stated legal rent without explaining the discounts actually provided to tenants. For underwriting purposes, purchasers and lenders should request concession agreements and payment histories, then examine whether projected renewal rents depend on treating those discounts as temporary.
Where that classification remains uncertain, the financial analysis should account for the possibility that future increases must be calculated from a lower rent. Identifying that issue before closing can inform pricing, diligence requests, and transaction negotiations.
The practical takeaway
DHCR’s clarification is a meaningful development for owners that have used temporary concessions or would like to use them in the future. Its value lies in reaffirming the need to examine the actual arrangement. Careful drafting, consistent administration, and a complete leasing record remain central to evaluating risk.
Sandman Malin PLLC advises property owners and managers, purchasers, and investors on rent regulation, leasing compliance, and regulatory due diligence, including the treatment of rent concessions and preferential rents.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Legal developments discussed are current as of November 17, 2026.